Top 10 Pizza Places in New York City: From Classic to Creative
Pizza’s roots trace back to Naples, where simple combinations of fermented thin dough, tomatoes, and fresh mozzarella captured European hearts. But when Italian immigrants crossed the Atlantic to New York, pizza evolved into something entirely new. While Chicago developed its deep-dish style for hearty meals, New York created its own iconic culture: thin, wide slices perfect for folding and eating on the go, matching the rhythm of a bustling city.
New York pizza is characterized by its oven-baked, crispy yet chewy crust, stretchy cheese with just the right amount of oil, and accessibility at an affordable price point. Today, NYC pizza rivals its Italian origins on the world stage. In 2024, Una Pizza Napoletana on the Lower East Side claimed the number one spot globally, while Lucali, L’industrie, and Don Antonio also earned international acclaim.
1. Una Pizza Napoletana (Lower East Side)
Why It’s #1: Crowned the world’s best pizza in 2024, surpassing countless Italian establishments.
Una Pizza Napoletana represents the pinnacle of traditional Neapolitan pizza-making in America. The commitment to authenticity is unwavering, with daily hand-made dough and limited quantities that sell out regularly. This artisanal approach has earned global recognition and devoted local following.
Must-Try Pizzas: Margherita, Marinara, Bianca
Location: 175 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002
Website: unapizza.com
2. L’industrie Pizzeria (Williamsburg)
Why It Stands Out: Winner of “Best Street Pizza” and a slice pizza innovator.
L’industrie revolutionized the New York slice with its thin, crispy crust topped with fresh mozzarella, Italian pepperoni, and creative combinations like hot honey. This Williamsburg hotspot has become a favorite among younger crowds seeking both quality and innovation.
Must-Try Slices: Burrata Slice, Pepperoni Slice
Location: 254 S 2nd St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Website: lindustriepizzeria.com
3. Lucali (Brooklyn)
Why It’s Legendary: Celebrity favorite with notoriously difficult reservations.
Chef Mark Iacono’s wood-fired pizzas represent New York pizza at its purest. The thin, crispy crust topped simply with fresh basil and mozzarella lets quality ingredients shine. Celebrities like Beyoncé and Jay-Z frequent this cash-only establishment, testament to its exceptional quality.
Must-Try Pizza: Plain Pie with toppings
Location: 575 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Website: lucali.com
Pro Tip: Cash only, reservations essential
4. Bleecker Street Pizza (Greenwich Village)
Why It’s Classic: Multiple “Best New York Pizza” awards.
Bleecker Street Pizza exemplifies perfect balance: thin, crispy dough, perfectly melted cheese, and harmonious tomato sauce. For purists seeking classic New York flavor, this Greenwich Village institution delivers consistently.
Must-Try Pizzas: Nonna Maria, Grandma Pie
Location: 69 7th Avenue South, New York, NY 10014
Website: bleeckerstreetpizza.com
5. Joe’s Pizza (Greenwich Village & Multiple Locations)
Why It’s Iconic: Featured in “Spider-Man” and a New York institution since 1975.
Joe’s Pizza represents the original New York slice experience. Unchanged since 1975, their thin, crispy crust with just the right amount of cheese and tomato sauce defines what a New York slice should be. This is pizza education for newcomers and nostalgia for locals.
Must-Try Slices: Plain Slice, Pepperoni Slice
Location: 7 Carmine St (multiple locations)
Website: joespizzanyc.com
6. Don Antonio (Midtown)
Why It’s Authentic: Third-generation Neapolitan pizza masters.
Run by a family of Neapolitan pizza artisans, Don Antonio brings authentic Naples to Manhattan. Their imported Naples oven produces perfectly chewy yet crispy pizzas, earning recognition as one of New York’s finest Neapolitan pizza destinations.
Must-Try Pizzas: Montanara, Pizza Fritta
Location: 309 W 50th St, New York, NY 10019
Website: donantoniopizza.com
7. Patsy’s Pizzeria (East Harlem)
Why It’s Historic: Est. 1933, pioneer of coal-oven pizza.
Patsy’s represents classic Neapolitan tomato pie heritage and originated charcoal oven pizza in America. The light dough carries deep smoky flavors from the coal-fired oven, creating a unique taste profile that’s been consistent for nearly a century.
Must-Try Pizza: Coal-Oven Cheese Pizza
Location: 2287 1st Ave, New York, NY 10035
Website: patsys.com
8. Prince Street Pizza (Nolita)
Why It’s Famous: The SoHo Square gained nationwide recognition.
Prince Street Pizza’s square slices loaded with spicy pepperoni have achieved cult status. The thick yet crispy dough combines with pepperoni oil to create deep, savory flavors that justify the frequent lines outside this Nolita shop.
Must-Try Pizzas: Spicy Spring, Prince Perfection
Location: 27 Prince St, New York, NY 10012
Website: princestreetpizza.com
9. Di Fara Pizza (Brooklyn)
Why It’s Legendary: Over half a century of handmade pizza excellence.
This Midwood institution earned praise from Anthony Bourdain for good reason. Fresh basil, quality olive oil, and hand-tossed dough combine in perfect harmony, creating what many consider the platonic ideal of New York pizza. Every pie is crafted with care by the same family for generations.
Must-Try Pizzas: Regular, Sicilian Slice
Location: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY 11230
Website: difarapizzany.com
10. Scarr’s Pizza (Lower East Side)
Why It’s Different: NYC’s only stone-milled slice pizzeria.
Scarr’s Pizza combines 1970s aesthetic with modern consciousness, using stone-milled flour and premium organic ingredients to create a new standard for New York pizza. The crispy yet chewy texture and fresh flavors appeal to a new generation while honoring tradition.
Must-Try Pizzas: Scarr’s Classic, Vodka Pie
Location: 35 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002
Website: scarrspizza.com
Honorable Mentions Worth Visiting
John’s of Bleecker Street (Greenwich Village) – Coal-oven pizza legend since 1915
Roberta’s (Brooklyn) – New wave pizza with fusion creativity, famous for Bee Sting pizza
Lombardi’s (Little Italy) – America’s first pizzeria, coal-oven Margherita perfection
L&B Spumoni Gardens (Brooklyn) – Beloved for Sicilian squares and spumoni ice cream
Grimaldi’s Pizzeria (DUMBO) – Classic Brooklyn coal-oven pizza
Juliana’s Pizza (DUMBO) – Another DUMBO favorite with deep roots
Stretch Pizza (Flatiron) – Modern American pizza laboratory with creative toppings
The New York Pizza Story
New York pizza absorbed Italian tradition, evolved beyond Chicago’s deep-dish alternative, and created its own genre. It embodies slice culture, street food sensibility, and world-class taste. This Top 10 list harmoniously blends tradition, innovation, and artisanal craftsmanship.
From a New Yorker’s daily staple to global culinary destination, each slice tells a story. That’s the magic of New York pizza – it’s not just food, it’s culture, history, and innovation baked into every bite.
Planning Your NYC Pizza Tour?
- Best for Authenticity: Una Pizza Napoletana, Don Antonio
- Best Classic Slice: Joe’s Pizza, Bleecker Street Pizza
- Best for Innovation: L’industrie, Scarr’s Pizza
- Best Traditional Experience: Di Fara, Patsy’s
- Celebrity Spotting: Lucali
- Best Square Slice: Prince Street Pizza
Whether you’re a first-time visitor or longtime resident, New York’s pizza scene offers endless delicious discoveries. Each pizzeria on this list represents excellence in its own right, contributing to the rich tapestry that makes New York the pizza capital of America.
New York’s Top 12 Hot Chocolates: From Christmas Market Mugs to Chocolatier Cups
5 Best Brunch Spots Near the Metropolitan Museum of Art (MET)
